SAHYOG Portal: X Corp’s Challenge in Delhi High Court
Why in the news
X (formerly Twitter) argued in the Delhi High Court that it cannot be forced onto the Centre’s SAHYOG portal, which raises questions about state control of online content.
About SAHYOG
- A government-led takedown platform for real-time coordination among law enforcement, social media firms and telecom providers.
- Follows an October 2023 MeitY memorandum under Section 79 of the IT Act.
Legal concerns
| Issue | Concern |
|---|---|
| Section 69A bypassed | 69A permits blocking only on specific grounds such as national security and public order, with written reasons, independent review and approval by a designated officer; SAHYOG lets many bodies, including state agencies and police, order takedowns |
| Censorship risk | No chance to contest requests and no independent oversight |
| Precedent | May be ultra vires and clash with Shreya Singhal vs Union of India (2015), which struck down vague, overbroad speech limits |
Legal challenge
- X filed petitions in the Delhi and Karnataka High Courts calling SAHYOG unconstitutional.
- The Ministry of Home Affairs must fully disclose SAHYOG details for transparency and to prevent misuse.
Implications
- Possible suppression of dissent; court rulings will decide constitutionality.
Exam angle
- Section 69A: blocking with safeguards; Section 79: intermediary provisions.
- Case: Shreya Singhal vs Union of India (2015).