Skip to content

SAHYOG Portal: X Corp’s Challenge in Delhi High Court

28 March 20251 min read
NATIONAL AFFAIRSSAHYOG Portal: XCorp’s Challengein Delhi High Court28 March 2025safalsetu.com

Why in the news

X (formerly Twitter) argued in the Delhi High Court that it cannot be forced onto the Centre’s SAHYOG portal, which raises questions about state control of online content.

About SAHYOG

  • A government-led takedown platform for real-time coordination among law enforcement, social media firms and telecom providers.
  • Follows an October 2023 MeitY memorandum under Section 79 of the IT Act.

Legal concerns

IssueConcern
Section 69A bypassed69A permits blocking only on specific grounds such as national security and public order, with written reasons, independent review and approval by a designated officer; SAHYOG lets many bodies, including state agencies and police, order takedowns
Censorship riskNo chance to contest requests and no independent oversight
PrecedentMay be ultra vires and clash with Shreya Singhal vs Union of India (2015), which struck down vague, overbroad speech limits

Legal challenge

  • X filed petitions in the Delhi and Karnataka High Courts calling SAHYOG unconstitutional.
  • The Ministry of Home Affairs must fully disclose SAHYOG details for transparency and to prevent misuse.

Implications

  • Possible suppression of dissent; court rulings will decide constitutionality.

Exam angle

  • Section 69A: blocking with safeguards; Section 79: intermediary provisions.
  • Case: Shreya Singhal vs Union of India (2015).

Test yourself

1. SAHYOG portal is linked to an October 2023 memorandum of MeitY under which section of the IT Act?

SAHYOG follows an October 2023 MeitY memorandum under Section 79.

2. Which Supreme Court judgment of 2015 is cited against vague, overbroad speech restrictions in the SAHYOG debate?

Shreya Singhal vs Union of India (2015) struck down vague provisions restricting speech.

3. X told which High Court that it cannot be compelled to join the SAHYOG portal?

X informed the Delhi High Court (and also petitioned the Karnataka High Court).